How to Choose Mushroom Coffee - Buying Tips

By Mushroom Naturals | Last Updated: 8th February 2025

Mushroom coffee has garnered significant attention as a health-conscious alternative to regular coffee. It offers a variety of wellness benefits alongside a gentler caffeine boost. With numerous available options, this article will guide you through the key factors to consider when choosing the best mushroom coffee, reassuring you that you're making a health-conscious choice.

Key Takeaways:

To choose the best mushroom coffee, look for a high-quality blend with functional mushrooms like Reishi, Lion's Mane, and Cordyceps that align with your health goals.
Consider the caffeine content, mushroom type, and ingredients to find a coffee that supports energy, focus, immunity, and digestion.
Look for organic, sustainably sourced mushroom coffee to ensure you get clean and effective products without fillers or additives.
Explore mushroom coffee's versatility with different brewing methods and taste enhancements. This will allow you to find the flavor and strength best suits your unique preferences, making your coffee experience truly personalized.

Table of Contents

How to Choose Mushroom Coffee

To choose the proper mushroom coffee for you, consider factors like the mushroom type, caffeine content, and quality of ingredients. Look for high-quality blends containing functional mushrooms such as Reishi, Lion's Mane, and Cordyceps to help focus, energy, immunity, and stress reduction. Additionally, ensure the coffee is free from unnecessary additives or fillers, and opt for organic or sustainably sourced options for the best quality.

How Do I Choose Mushroom Coffee That’s Right for Me?

The best approach to choosing mushroom coffee is to align your selection with your health goals and personal preferences.

Top tips:

Health Goals: Consider what health benefits are most important to you. For example, a coffee with Lion's Mane may be ideal if you're looking to boost focus and mental clarity. If you want to reduce stress, go for Reishi. Additionally, mushroom coffee has been studied for its potential benefits in managing conditions like anxiety, depression, and cognitive decline. If you're interested in these specific health concerns, it's best to consult a healthcare professional for personalized advice.
Caffeine Sensitivity: If you’re sensitive to caffeine, choose a mushroom coffee blend with lower caffeine content. Many mushroom coffee brands offer decaf options or blends with much less caffeine than regular coffee.
Flavor Preference: Mushroom coffee can have a slightly earthy flavor, but you can adjust the taste with sweeteners, milk alternatives, or other flavorings to suit your palalate.

What to Look for When Buying Mushroom Coffee?

There are several key factors to consider when purchasing mushroom coffee:

Mushroom Types: Different mushrooms offer different benefits. Lion’s Mane supports focus, Cordyceps boosts energy, and Reishi is known for stress relief. Choose a blend that aligns with your wellness goals.
Caffeine Content: If you’re cutting back on caffeine or want to avoid jitters, look for blends with lower caffeine content. Many mushroom coffees contain half the caffeine of regular coffee.
Quality of Ingredients: Always check the product label for organic certification and ensure no fillers or artificial additives exist. High-quality mushroom coffee blends use mushroom extracts rather than the less potent mycelium (mushroom root).
Third-Party Testing: For peace of mind, look for brands that undergo third-party testing to ensure purity and potency.

What is Mushroom Coffee?

Mushroom coffee is a blend of regular and medicinal mushrooms, creating a beverage that combines the rich taste of coffee with the wellness benefits of functional mushrooms. These mushrooms, such as Reishi, Lion's Mane, Cordyceps, and Chaga, are packed with antioxidants, adaptogens, and other compounds that support mental clarity, immune health, stress reduction, and digestive function.

Unlike regular coffee with a higher caffeine content, mushroom coffee typically has less caffeine. Thus, it provides a more balanced, sustained energy boost without jitters or crashes.

How is Mushroom Coffee Made?

Mushroom coffee combines medicinal mushrooms with regular coffee or coffee grounds.

The Process:

Mushroom Selection & Extraction – High-quality mushrooms are carefully harvested and extracted to preserve their bioactive compounds. Dual extraction methods can ensure that both water-soluble and fat-soluble compounds are captured.
Blending with Coffee – The mushroom extract is blended with ground coffee beans or instant coffee. Some mushroom coffee blends use a 50:50 ratio of coffee to mushroom extract, but you can adjust the ratio to suit your taste.
Packaging – The final blend is packaged and tested for purity and effectiveness, ensuring that it retains the beneficial properties of the mushrooms.

How is Mushroom Coffee Different from Regular Coffee?

While both mushroom coffee and regular coffee are brewed from coffee beans, mushroom coffee offers several advantages:

Lower Caffeine: Mushroom coffee contains less caffeine, providing a smoother energy boost that’s gentler on the body.
Added Health Benefits: Mushroom coffee is infused with adaptogens like Reishi, Lion’s Mane, and Cordyceps, which can help with stress relief, immune function, and cognitive support.
Reduced Jitters: Because of its lower caffeine content and the presence of adaptogens, mushroom coffee offers a more stable energy boost without the usual jitters that come from drinking regular coffee.

Types of Mushroom Coffee You Can Make

There are several ways to enjoy mushroom coffee, depending on your preferences:

Instant mushroom coffee is the fastest and most convenient option. Mix the powder with hot water, and your mushroom-infused coffee will be ready in seconds.
Ground mushroom coffee is the way to go if you prefer freshly brewed coffee. Brew it using a drip coffee maker, French press, or pour-over method, like regular coffee.
For a customized experience, mix the mushroom powder with your regular coffee grounds. This allows you to control the strength of the coffee and the mushroom benefits based on your preferences.

How to Make Mushroom Coffee from Scratch

Making mushroom coffee from scratch allows you to personalize the taste while tailoring it to your health goals. Here’s how:

Gather mushroom powder (from your preferred mushrooms), coffee grounds, and water. Optionally, you can add milk or sweeteners to taste.
Look for organic mushroom powders from reputable brands that use fruiting bodies (not just mycelium), as these contain more potent active compounds.
Add half a teaspoon of mushroom powder to your coffee grounds and brew as usual. Adjust the amount based on your desired strength and taste.
You can make pure mushroom coffee using powder and water to eliminate caffeine.

Brewing Mushroom Coffee at Home: The Different Methods

Mushroom coffee can be brewed using a variety of methods. Here’s how to brew it with different tools:

French Press: Add mushrooms and regular coffee grounds (if desired) to your French press. Pour in hot water, stir, and let it steep for 3-5 minutes. Press down and pour your coffee into a cup.
Drip Coffee Maker: To use this method, add mushroom coffee grounds to the filter instead of regular coffee grounds and brew as usual.
Espresso Machine: Use mushroom coffee grounds in your machine like regular coffee grounds. Adjust the amount depending on your desired intensity.
Pour-Over: Place mushroom coffee grounds in a filter and slowly pour hot water over them, allowing the water to drip into your cup.
Moka Pot: You can use a moka pot to brew mushroom coffee using the same method as regular coffee.

How to Make Iced Mushroom Coffee

Mix mushroom coffee grounds with cold water to cold-brew mushroom coffee. Let it steep in the fridge for 12-24 hours, then strain and serve over ice.

Blend mushroom coffee, banana, almond milk, and protein powder for a nutritious, post-workout smoothie.

Can You Mix Mushroom Coffee with Regular Coffee?

Mixing mushroom coffee with regular coffee can give you the benefits of both—the caffeine boost from regular coffee and the health benefits of medicinal mushrooms.

Combining mushroom coffee with regular coffee gives a more decisive caffeine kick, and the added adaptogens help balance the effects of caffeine.

Mushroom coffee’s adaptogens can help reduce jitteriness caused by the higher caffeine content in regular coffee.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Drinking Mushroom Coffee

To get the most out of your mushroom coffee, avoid these common mistakes:
Start with a smaller serving and gradually increase to avoid digestive discomfort.
Choose the correct brewing method that suits your taste and coffee preferences.
Ensure your mushroom coffee uses high-quality, organic ingredients for the best health benefits.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can You Make Mushroom Coffee Without a Coffee Maker?

You can use instant mushroom coffee or mushroom powder mixed with hot water.

2. How Long Does It Take to Brew Mushroom Coffee?

Depending on the brewing method, it typically takes 5-10 minutes.

3. Is Homemade Mushroom Coffee as Effective as Store-Bought?

Yes, as long as you’re using high-quality mushroom powder.

4. Can You Use Whole Mushrooms Instead of Mushroom Powder?

Extracting active compounds from whole mushrooms may be more challenging without proper processing.

5. How Do You Store Homemade Mushroom Coffee?

Store in a cool, dry place to maintain freshness and potency.

Mushroom Coffee Guide

Disclaimer: This site is purely for informational purposes. The products we recommended are not intended to disagnose, treat, cure , or prevent any disease.

Consult with a doctor before using any product we recommend. The products we recommend are also not intended for pregnant people, serious medical conditions, or children under the age of 18.

Address: 176 Pearl St, Brooklyn, New York, NY 11201, United States | Customer Support: support@mushroomnaturals.com | Business Enquiries: info@mushroomnaturals.com | Shipping & Returns: return@mushroomnaturals.com | Customer Support Number: +1-855-709-6933